wa 'alaikum as salaam wa rahmatu Allahi wa barakatuh,
It is interesting analysis that I disagreed with the first time I read it. However, I changed my views over time in light of other evidence. So, the more I come across the argument, "Children should memorize when young and understand when older" has become more and more unconvincable due to scientific findings in language acquisition, educational and developmental psychologist suggestions, along with observations from earlier generations in Islamic History. Ibn Khaldun chastises those who use this ineffective and inefficient method for reasons explained in his book. This is another example from Islamic History with the same point:
"At the time of Abu Darda Quran was written on bones, leaves and pieces of leather. These days the Quran
is decorated so much that people don’t even want to touch it and read it because it looks so good! If
people were to see the Quran written on bones or other pieces, they would be quick to say that such a
thing is disrespect to the Quran. Yet people do not think that not following the Quran is disrespect to it.
We have lost track of what Quran should do for us and how we should study the Book of Allah (swt).
Allaah says:
‘(This is) a Book (the Qur'an) which We have sent down to you, full of blessings that they may
ponder over its Verses, and that men of understanding may remember.’ [Surah Saad: Verse 29]
‘Do they not then think deeply in the Qur'an, or are their hearts locked up (from understanding it)?’
[Surah Muhammad: Verse 24]
Allaah (swt) is not only asking us to recite the Quran, rather He is asking us to meditate and contemplate
over the Quran. We have to have ‘tatabbur’ (deep contemplation).
How did the Sahabah study the Quran? If we take the example of Abdullah ibn Umar (radiAllahu anhu), he
says: ‘It took me 14 years to finish memorizing Surah Baqarah.’ He (radiAllahu anhu) was so happy after
memorizing it, he said ‘and then I slaughtered a camel and I invited all the people to come.’ It was such an important
event for him that he made a day of celebration of behalf of it. We can memorize Quran now within a
year- how come it took Abdullah ibn Umar 14 years? The reason is, as narrated by one of the Tabieen, who
said, ‘I met with some of the Sahabah of the Rasul (saws) and they told me that the way they would study
Quran is that they would take ten verses and they would study these ten verses, they would study the
eemaan, the ilm, and the halal and haram in the verses, then memorize the verses and then move onto the
next ten verses. They would never move onto the next ten verses until they applied it. Not until it became
alive and a second nature to them. I was told this by many of the Sahabah, not just one.’
Imam Ahmed al Ghazali said, ‘I memorized Quran when I was 10 years old. Because of the mode I was in (of just
reciting without learning and understanding), when I grew up and was attempting to understand the Book of Allaah, I was
finding it very hard because I was programmed to just repeat the verses It took me a lot of effort and struggle until I was able
to break that cycle and start thinking and contemplating over the ayaat of Allaah (swt).’ He was talking about a
problem that we have in the modern education of teaching the whole Quran without any understanding.
He was talking about the common memorization that takes place amongst kids without any understanding.
We have to go through struggle in order to understand the Book of Allaah. One key that might help us is
that the Book of Allaah does not throw upon us gems; it does not offer us the benefit unless we are keen
for learning and receiving the guidance. This is something that is interesting about the Quran. Allaah (swt)
says:
‘And We send down from the Qur'an that which is a healing and a mercy to those who believe (in
Islamic Monotheism and act on it), and it increases the Zalimun (polytheists and wrong-doers) nothing
but loss.’ [Surah Isra: Verse 82]
Quran draws some people close and it draws some people further. If you want to benefit from Quran, it
will benefit you and if you do not then Allaah (swt) will honour His Book. This is part of the uniqueness of
Allaah. The point isn’t that we take 40 years to memorize Surah Baqarah but it is that we make sure we
implement what we memorize. The Prophet (saws) said, "In the last days (of the world) there will appear young
people with foolish thoughts and ideas. They will give good talks, but they will go out of Islam as an arrow goes out of its game,
their faith will not exceed their throats..." [Bukhari
an excerpt from an article:
http://www.kalamullah.com/Books/Understanding%20the%20Quran.pdfAnd I keep wondering when, where, how and why, did this method of 'memorizing without a basic understanding' develop in Islamic History? Part of the answer is in an enlightening paper of "Madrassah History" by Dr. Uzma, a respected Professor of Education:
Islamic Education
A Brief History of Madrassas With
Comments on Curricula and Current Pedagogical Practices
http://www.uvm.edu/~envprog/madrassah/madrassah-history.pdfI wish I could also find the history of the Maghrebi tradition, that Ibn Khaldun noted so long ago, but will have to look for someone to help me with that, insha'Allah. I have many more examples such as these, if you are interested in them, but these will suffice for now. Wa Allahu 'alim.
We began our sessions as short and fun, and the time gradually increased, but it is too much now - and with them attending school, it is more of a challenge. And as long as a student is interested in learning any subject, they will naturally develop a prolonged attention span - however, when it is forced (or less of a personal choice for the student) they will not and will gradually shun it. This claim is also supported by a lot of scientific research in educational and developmental psychology, and one of the main reasons why the modern American schooling system is failing miserably, while on the other educational models such as the Montessori method, which guide the child to discover what they are interested in.
So, for us, my focus has changed to a slower schedule that focuses more on building up vocabulary (word recognition/pronunciation/basic understanding) and correct recitation, and to encourage a love of learning Qur'an, while allowing them to choose it for themselves. One example comes to mind is the world famous Qaria Hajjah Maria, who actually ran away (to an aunts house) when it came time for her daily evening Qur'aan classes, because her parents forced her to practice everyday, and when they allowed her to make it a choice for herself, is when she returned to it and became the top female reciter in the world, masha'Allah.
http://www.saudiaramcoworld.com/issue/200003/recited.from.the.heart.htmFor us, I can sense my children dread it and this their warning sign that I have to adapt to their needs and interests and without too many external rewards which are actually self defeating in the long term. When I also discuss it with a friend who has a master's degree in educational psychology and is working on her Ph.D. in the same field, with am emphasis on 'Qur'anic Memorization', she gave the same advice. So, for me at this particular point, I have tried - and failed - to ignore or change what educational and developmental psychologists have discovered and advised, for sake of keeping what is a essentially a cultural tradition with regard to tafeedh. As depressing as it feels at times, I am hopeful that since our daily routine involves Qur'an for our nuclear family members and most of our closest extended family members, it is a positive model for them, insha'Allah. And to address the issue of diglossia in Arabic, we also incorporate fushaah and 'ameeyah into our daily studies to make it more interesting and try to tie it back to the Qur'an somehow, but not always.
For me - at this particular time - and perhaps you can sense it - is that I am very frustrated, and I hope we can continue with learning 3 lines per day and gradually increase to 5 and then half a page, which is the daily limit my husband is comfortable with. But if not, then I am prepared to just learn 1 line per day minimum. I just remember in the beginning, it was more enjoyable for all of us when the sessions were short. It is the increasing review time and corrections that are the challenge. So, I will also begin taking them to our neighbor who is working on her ijaazah, masha'Allah, and perhaps having another teacher will help ease the process. I will continue with teach them the words and connecting and the meanings, and after they learn the surah, they can recite to her for corrections. In the meantime, I am reminded of the hadith that the most beloved act to Allah, is one that may be small, yet is consistent. Du'as, please.