So this is rather off topic to right brain education but I have been thinking of this in regards to technology or no technology. I like the simple idea of the Robinson stuff and the no technology appeals to me as I was brought up for most of my childhood with no tv or computer and I loved to read. And it scares me how powerful tv/video/computer is. But our children are coming into a very different world than I did. When I got to universiversity I had to suddenly use a computer for word processing and that was it (this was 20 years ago!) and I remember how stressed I was. By the time my children get to university level everything will be on the computer. They will be using it for things that I can't even imagine. And they will be using devices (not just computers) for things that I can't even dream of. For me, technology didn't change that much to when I had to use it so it wasn't a huge gap for me to overcome. Now technology is changing so fast that the gap/learning curve of someone not familiar with at least some of it will be huge. Am I actually doing their education and their ability to integrate and use these technologies to learn a diservice if I restrict them in their learning now. If there is an easier way to learn something by watching DVDs or using technology why not use it? As Tamsyn suggests maybe it is rewiring their brain to learn differently (well, not maybe, we all know it is that is why it bothers us) but that differently is probably 'normal'. Do we need to let them watch hours of cartoons and play random games to do that - no. But I think maybe we should expose them to some things at least and encourage the use of technology in their education.
Simple example, when I was a kid you were taught to pick up the phone and dial 000 (or 911) in an emergency. Now, I have had to teach my child how to do that. We only have mobile phones so it goes more like this
First, find the phone!
Then, press the sequence to unlock the keys.
Next, find the number keypad display by pressing the appropriate icon/button
Then press 000/911
Finally press call.
And in 6 - 12 months time when I have a new phone it will be different again (and of course everyone else's phone is slightly different so if he is with someone else or somewhere else he needs to know how to work their phone).
So, maybe we are rewiring our children's brains to a more fast flashing, fluid, non linear, think outside the square type approach but maybe we need to for them to survive in this world.
I found this ed talk that was part of another thread here very interesting.
http://www.youtube.com/v/y3jYVe1RGaU&rel=1Look at the results that he gets by putting a computer in a slum with children with almost no education. Technology opens up a whole world of learning that wasn't even thought possibly a few years ago.
As Tamsyn says will it be setting our kids up for ADD type behavious. Possibly, but is that what is needed? I honestly don't know. I'm not really sure where I stand at this point. The RC no technology appeals to me as I said - old fashioned 3R's - but then I see my son's excitement/interest and how much he learns from some science youtube videos that I could never teach him and he would never read in a book at this age.