Doc that's exactly the way my dad taught us math in the 70's and 80's
i'm sending him the link now
looking at the sites was so weired for me

karma for the link
Kimba15
my daughter didn't click with the dots either
i firmly believe it works better with visual learners
manipulatives worked wonders with my daughter
she started Singapore Math at 2.8 years old and has loved every minute of it
now a year later she is starting the first grade program and doing really well
we still use the math dot cards 1 though 20 to help teach quantity
and some times she enjoys placing small stones or bears on top of each dot
we started using LM again after almost a year break
she is older now so i just let her play with it however she likes
we also use it to practice math facts and other things she learns in SM like even and odd numbers etc
i'm just so glad that she enjoys math and thinks it's really fun