Now this is a topic that is near and dear to my heart. Thank you dad dude for your interesting comments, the rest of you as well. I have been doing EK with my 4 year old with Down syndrome since he was about 1.5. I persevered for 2 years with little to no results, then finally at age 3.5 he suddenly decided to show me that he was taking in what I was teaching. The question now is, is this just a neat parlour trick or is there true value. I contend that there is great value in this and I will tell you why. Be warned, my response is rather lengthy. Josiah is only 4 and will be 5 at the end of the month but already I see how learning these facts is helping him to think better.
Let me give you an example of something we are currently working on to illustrate. I am hoping to get this on video in the next few weeks and I will post when I do.
I have been teaching Josiah some art. I have pictures of 10 painting from Van Gogh, Monet, Rembrandt, Renoir and Gauguin. I started more or less by flashing a set of one artist at a time. I then introduced the next and so on. After I felt he knew 4 fairly well I laid the self portrait of each artist on the table then randomly would say the name of a painting and show it to him and ask him who painted it. He would say the name of the artist and place it under his picture. (Josiah has only just learned to speak within the last 2 months, he used to point to show me the answer. He had some words before but now he is putting them together and speech really seems to make sense to him now)
When Josiah could do 4 artists and 40 paintings I introduce Gauguin and within days he could distinguish his paintings as well. To exercise a different part of the brain I sometimes just ask him "Who painted, The Potato Eaters" for example and he will say "Van Gogh. So he is using visual and auditory memory. My next experiment will be to show him paintings he has never seen by these artists and see if he can distinguish by style. I hope to do that soon but want to have a video going.
I do believe there is value in straight memory work as a brain building activity but I also believe that it is better to layer the learning which is what I am trying to do. We also do flags and eventually he will learn the flag of France, and that Renoir and Monet were French. Then one day I will have him divide the artists by nationality for example. My point is that there will be some independent thinking going on.
To illustrate further why I believe this is building his brain power I will give you an example that has nothing to do with EK. After Christmas we began playing a game called A fist full of coins.
http://fistfullofcoins.moonfruit.com , if you check it out the following may make more sense. This game helps to develop processing skills. Children with Down syndrome typically have great difficulty in this area. I believe that the things I have been doing with Josiah such as EK have helped him to the point that he could follow these Level 1 instructions in the game such as “Put the yellow moon under the red heart box”. He folds his hand while I read the instructions and when I am done reading he does what I read. Another example is “turn the yellow square box upside down and put the orange diamond on top of it.” In 5 months Josiah completed Level 1 (15 card) and we have just begun Level 2. An instruction he has completed in L2 is “Put the orange button under the green oval box and put the purple car in the box”
This game says it’s for ages 5 and up. Josiah is 4, with Down syndrome and I believe that the EK we have been doing for the past 3+ years has contributed to helping him think better. I could be wrong but I am convince it has made a difference.
If you are interested here is a 2 minute video I put together entitled Are you smarter than a 3 year old with Down syndrome. I have posted it on a forum before but since it is relevant to the topic I will repost. I realize that the video alone proves nothing, but hopefully the other comments I have made make my point.
http://www.youtube.com/v/N9NqHcHNWWA&rel=1